Monday, April 5, 2010

Linguistically Challenged

Mostly, I listen. I listen for familiar words and phrases, for the rhythm and cadence of the language, for idiomatic expressions and exclamations! I've been listening for almost 10 yearsattending Italian classesalbiet 2 hours a week of studying grammar, reading articles, trying to string 2 or 3 sentences together and learning to roll the r's. I listen to (and watch) the same episodes of Italian TV soap operas over and over and over on my computer, until the characters seem like real people in my life. I listen to songs by Laura Pausini, Andrea Bocelli and others who sing in Italian, attempting to understand what the hell they were singing about. I have watched and listened to countless hours of RAI Telegiornale, to the point of knowing the Italian politicians and their scandals!

I listen. And I understand. Capisco. But speaking is not coming easily. I want to speak correctly. I know how to conjugate the verbs, how to use the pronouns...even combine them…hello!!...glielo!! … but I just can't seem to get the words out. Everyone advises me to “...just talk. Don’t worry about the correct verb form”. But I was doing that 10 years ago. I'm not making progress here! I'm afraid that if I keep talking in the present tense and broken sentences that I will never improve.

Part of the problem is that Italians talk very fast. They also listen very fast. They cant wait for me to get out all of the words that I need to say what I mean. It's hard to have a conversation when everyone wants to finish my sentences. And it doesn't help me get comfortable wrapping my tongue around all the syllables. Another part of the problem is that I spend too much time thinking of how to say something, instead of following the conversation. In a nutshell, I dont speak spontaneously.

For years, I've been telling myself that my speaking ability would improve if only I could spend a few months in Italy, speaking only Italian. Well, here Im…and I feel like I'm regressing. I get tongue tied and my brain is functioning on a 7 second delay.

The other day, I poked my head out the kitchen window to say “buon giorno” to the woman who was out on the terrazzo below. The apartment has been empty during the week but occupied on weekends (actually, this is only our second weekend). So I said buon giorno and was surprised by her response. Instead of a pleasant reply, she was telling me that I couldn't use the laundry drying rack outside my window because it hung over her terrace. She went on to say that they'd be eating out on the terrazzo, that I should move the rack to another window, where it wouldn't disturb their meals. I don't use the rack anyway, because it's kind of flimsy, but it works for a dish towel or something lightweight.

I was speechless. I understood completely what she was saying, but the only words that came out were “ va bene,va bene” and “OK, non problema”, even as proper responses swirled through my brain, such as:

“The landlord hung the rack here. I can ask him to move it.”

“ It won't be a problem since I don't hang dripping laundry from here anyway.”

“ We've just been here a few weeks, and I haven't had the pleasure. Hi, I'm Carol , what's your name? Are you here for weekends only, or all the time? “

This is simply not going well. It's been 3 weeks already and I'm still not fluent!

10 comments:

  1. Great post, made me laugh on this bitterly cold Pasquetta!

    To some of us languages come easily and to others with great difficulty. I am in the second category so I understand completely what you are saying.

    ReplyDelete
  2. LLM- Thank you! How long have you been at it? Speaking English at home isn't helping either! Boh!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Carol...Pazienza..and a lot of it! Someone told me that the secret to learning a new language is to learn it the way you learned your native tongue. NO grammer,No conjugations.....not even reading & writing..that comes later...just talking and listening all the time. However, you are a prolific writer of English. You have a way of making the story compelling and drawing the reader in. At the end of a year you'll have a very intersting book.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I feel your pain! I'm so glad to hear someone has the same difficulty speaking Italian that I do. I'm not quite there on the comprehensive yet (only been studying 3 years) but I surely struggle to put more than 3 words together in a sentence. I listen to songs, Italian TV and watch Italian movies purchased from Italy so I can view the Italian sottotitoli and am under the impression if I could just spent a year in Italy I might learn to speak! I will eagerly read your progress. Glad I found this blog. In bocca al lupo!

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is THE BEST POST! Haha...it is about the age of the brain learning languages, Carol. That said, I am happy to tell you I understand the phrase 'non Capisco' as I used it a few times. I actually formed sentences using it after practicing to an Italian language DC in preparation for the Italian trip a few years ago. I never presumed to learn the language but I wanted them to think that I was at least trying. My French for the Paris trip amounted to the proper inflection for "bon jour"...this after listening to them.

    ...by the way, you lost me on "conjugate", it sounds too much like something else!

    MLK (not Martin Luther King)

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Roberto/Bobby - Grazie mille. Sei molto gentile :)

    Kristen - In bocca al lupo anche a te!!

    MLK -Maureen, is that you???

    Michael - non vedo l'ora!! Grazie!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Ciao Carol! I read with compassion your blog today. It will come! you are there in Italy surrounded by the language...I am sure you will make the most of it...find some one who is simpatico and practice the language with them. My frustration is that there are so few Italian speakers here in California! I too would love to be immersed in the language...so am doubly jealous! I always think I would speak at lightening speed and understand so much more if I just lived there.

    But, in the end, you still need to do the work and make your brain turn the corner. I find writing my blog in Italian has improved my language skills and that I am thinking more in Italian and dreaming more in Italian...and whipping off Italian phrases with my non Italian speaking family seems more natural then ever and not forced or so foreign.

    If you ever want to practice via skype with me...would love to!

    p.s. are you still watching Capri...do you watch Un posto al sole!?!?!

    ReplyDelete
  9. melissa, molto grazie. Si, continuo di seguire Capri, pero' la prossimo puntata e l'ultimo puntata della tersa serie. Si ho avuto comminciato di seguire <Un posto al Sole. E' una cosa strano che le puntate non sono in onde ogni settimana allo stesso tempo. Cambiano le giorni..... si fa difficile di seguirlo......Boh!!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Carol,

    Your neighbor is testing you - she would never tell an Italian to move their laundry rack or not to hang clothes on it. It's just how it is here -by the way I am an Italian. Don't let her bully you.

    ReplyDelete